When does PMI automatically come off?
On the date your balance is first scheduled to reach 78% of the original value,
provided you are current. The servicer must do it without being asked and without an
appraisal.
The word scheduled is doing a lot of work. It means the original amortisation schedule,
so if you have paid extra principal your actual balance got there earlier and the
automatic date did not move.
Can I get PMI removed early?
Yes, and there are two separate ways. You can request cancellation once the balance
reaches 80% of the original value, which is a right under the Act. Or you can ask the
servicer to cancel based on a new appraisal showing today's value, which is
investor policy rather than law, and is usually much earlier if the property has
appreciated.
Both require you to ask. Neither happens on its own.
Does paying extra principal get rid of PMI faster?
It moves the 80% request date, sometimes by years. It does not move the 78% automatic
date at all, because that one runs off the original schedule.
So overpaying is worth real money here, but only if you follow it with a written
cancellation request. Pay extra and wait for the servicer and you will have bought
nothing.
Does my house going up in value remove PMI?
Not through the Act. The 80% and 78% routes are both measured against the
original value, the lesser of what you paid and what it appraised for at
closing, so appreciation does nothing for either.
It helps through the investor's appraisal route, which uses today's value: two to five
years in at 75%, or more than five years in at 80%. In a market that has risen that is
normally the earliest date available, and it is the one most borrowers have never heard
of.
How much does it cost to get an appraisal to remove PMI?
You pay for it, and the servicer normally orders it rather than accepting one you
bring. Ask what it will cost and what value you need before committing, an
appraisal that comes back short is money spent for nothing.
Weigh it against what you are paying: at $200 a month, an appraisal that ends the
premium two years early pays for itself many times over. At $60 a month and six months
early, it does not.
Does FHA mortgage insurance ever go away?
On a loan endorsed on or after 3 June 2013, only if the original loan-to-value was at
or below 90%, then it ends after 11 years. Above 90% it runs for the life of the
loan.
Because the minimum FHA down payment is 3.5%, most FHA borrowers are in the
life-of-loan group. Refinancing out of FHA is the only thing that ends it, which makes
it a very different decision from a conventional loan where waiting works.
What is the midpoint rule?
A backstop. The premium cannot be charged beyond the midpoint of the amortisation
period, after payment 180 on a 30-year loan, if you are current, whatever
the balance has done.
It rarely binds on an ordinary fixed-rate loan, because the balance reaches 78% well
before then. It matters on a modified loan, a very long term, or one with an
interest-only period.
The date has passed and I am still being charged. What now?
If the automatic termination date has passed and you were current, that is a servicing
error rather than something to negotiate. Put it in writing, cite the date, and ask for
the premiums collected since then to be refunded, the Act requires the return of
unearned premiums.
Keep the correspondence. If it is not resolved, it can be escalated to the Consumer
Financial Protection Bureau.
Why can't I cancel? I am well under 80%.
The usual reasons, in order of frequency: you are measuring against today's value
rather than the original value; there is a second lien on the property, including a home
equity line you opened and never used; there is a late payment inside the lookback
window; or the loan is not a primary residence, where the thresholds are higher.
The second-lien one catches people constantly, and closing an unused line is often the
whole job.
My mortgage insurance is not on my statement at all.
Then it is probably lender-paid, and the cost sits inside your interest rate instead.
None of the cancellation rules apply to it, there is no monthly charge to end,
and it lasts for the life of the loan. A refinance is the only way out.
The same applies if the premium was paid as a single lump sum at closing.
Does a VA loan have mortgage insurance to remove?
No. VA charges no monthly mortgage insurance at all, there is a one-time funding
fee and that is the whole of it. There is nothing to cancel and nothing to wait for.
USDA is the opposite case: its annual fee runs for the life of the loan, like most FHA
loans.
Should I refinance just to get rid of it?
Sometimes, and it is arithmetic rather than a rule. On an FHA loan above 90% original
loan-to-value it is the only exit, so the question is simply whether the new rate and
costs beat the premium you would otherwise pay indefinitely.
On a conventional loan it is almost never worth refinancing purely to end a premium
that is going to end anyway on a date you can look up. Work out the date first, it is often closer than people assume.