How much house can I afford on my income?
There is no answer from income alone, which is why every calculator that asks for only
your income is guessing. The same income produces wildly different maximums depending on
what you already owe each month, how much cash you have, what the property taxes are
where you are buying, and which programme you use.
What income does tell you is the ceiling on your payment: your monthly debts
subtracted from a percentage of your gross income. Turning that payment into a price
then depends on the rate, the taxes, the insurance and the mortgage insurance, and the price that comes out is only your maximum if cash and the county limit do not
stop you first.
What debt-to-income ratio do I need to buy a house?
It depends on the programme, and two of the three have no fixed ceiling.
Conventional stops hard at 50% through Desktop Underwriter. FHA publishes 31% and 43%
as guidelines, but a loan approved by the TOTAL Scorecard is not bound by them. VA has
no ratio ceiling at all, 41% is a guideline above which the file needs residual
income 20% above the requirement or a written justification.
So the honest answer is that the ratio is a ceiling on conventional and a signal
everywhere else.
Why does this show three different maximum prices?
Because you are three different borrowers to three different rulebooks. They disagree
about how much you must put down, how your student loans are counted, what mortgage
insurance costs you, how large a loan the county permits, and what test you have to
pass.
The differences are not small. It is routine for the spread between the highest and
lowest of the three to be six figures on the same income and the same debts.
Which is better, FHA or conventional?
Neither, in general. At a lower credit score FHA is usually better, because FHA charges
every borrower the same mortgage insurance premium while conventional prices it by
score, at 620 the conventional factor can be three times the one a 760 pays, and
FHA does not care. At a high score conventional is usually better, because its premium
gets very cheap and it comes off when you reach 78% of the original value, while FHA's
runs for the life of the loan on anything above 90%.
The crossover is real and it moves with the market. That is what the comparison above
is for.
Does a student loan I am not paying still count against me?
On FHA, yes. FHA uses your documented payment, and where that payment is zero it uses
0.5% of the balance, so a $0 never counts as $0. On a
conventional loan, a verified $0 payment under an income-driven plan qualifies at $0,
but a loan that is deferred or in forbearance is counted at 1% of the balance. On VA it
is excluded entirely if repayment begins more than twelve months after closing.
This single difference is frequently the largest one between the programmes for a
younger borrower, and it is worth checking before deciding anything else.
Should I pay off my car to qualify for more?
Only if your ratio is what is binding you, and only if paying it off does not
take the cash you need to close. Those two things are frequently in direct conflict, and
clearing a debt with money you needed at the table simply swaps one ceiling for another.
The lever panel above runs this properly: it re-solves the whole model with the debt
removed and shows what actually happens to the maximum price, including the case where
the answer is nothing at all.
One thing worth checking first: an instalment debt with ten or fewer payments left may
already be excluded, in which case paying it off buys you nothing.
How much cash do I need?
The down payment, plus closing costs, plus prepaid taxes and insurance. On a $600,000
purchase with 5% down that is $30,000 of down payment and often another $15,000 to
$20,000 of costs and prepaids.
Cash is the binding constraint on a very large share of first purchases, and when it is,
the useful conversation is about seller credits, lender credits, gift funds and down
payment assistance, none of which touch your ratio, and all of which move this
ceiling.
Is VA residual income really more important than the ratio?
On a VA loan, yes. It is the test that governs, and it is the one that most often
decides the maximum, ahead of the ratio, the cash and the loan limit.
It also behaves differently from a ratio: because the requirement is a fixed dollar
amount by household size and region rather than a percentage, a larger household needs
more left over on the same income, and a larger house needs more again through the
maintenance allowance.
Why is the comfort number so much lower than the approval?
Because they measure different things. An underwriter asks whether the documented
income supports the documented obligations. Nobody at that desk is asked about
childcare, commuting, saving, or what you want your life to look like, none of
which appear on a credit report.
The comfort figure here is one stated rule, and you can change the percentage in the
form. Its only real job is to make the gap visible so it is a decision rather than an
accident.
Does my credit score change how much house I can buy?
On a conventional loan, yes, through mortgage insurance, the premium is priced
by score and loan-to-value together, and moving up a score band lowers the monthly
premium, which lowers the payment, which raises the price you qualify for. It also
affects the rate you are offered, which this page does not attempt to guess.
On FHA it does not: every borrower pays the same premium. On VA there is no monthly
mortgage insurance to price at all.
What is the 28/36 rule, and should I use it?
It is a rule of thumb: housing at or below 28% of gross income, total debts at or below
36%. No agency requires it and no automated underwriting system applies it.
It is not useless, as a budgeting instinct it is reasonable, and it is roughly
where the comfort figure on this page starts. But it is not what anyone will underwrite
you to, and using it as an affordability ceiling will understate what you can buy,
sometimes by a great deal.
Can I use this as a pre-approval?
No. It is an estimate from figures you typed, and nothing here has been verified. A
pre-approval requires a credit report, income and asset documentation, and an automated
underwriting decision on the real file.
Use this to work out which of your own numbers to fix first, and what to ask about.
Then get pre-approved before you write an offer.
Do property taxes really change what I can afford?
A great deal. Taxes sit inside the payment the ratio is measured against, so a county
at 2.2% instead of 1.1% cuts the price you qualify for substantially on the same
income.
The same is true of association dues, which count in full, and of homeowner's
insurance, which has moved sharply in several states. Two identical buyers in two
counties are not approved for the same price.
What if I am self-employed?
The mechanics above still apply, but the income figure is the hard part and this page
cannot work it out for you. Qualifying income for a self-employed borrower is generally
a two-year average of net income after deductions, with certain items added back, and
it is often far lower than what the business takes in.
Put your best estimate of that figure into the income field rather than your revenue or
your deposits, and treat the result as provisional until someone has read the returns.